
All Are Welcome
About All Are Welcome
A community-focused bakery and cafe serving exceptional pastries and locally roasted coffee in a light-filled space.
What reviewers say about All Are Welcome
Housed in a converted Christian Science Reading Room, this Northcote institution is celebrated for its world-class artisanal pastries and specialty coffee. Reviewers consistently praise the inventive menu items like khachapuri and medovnik alongside perfectly executed traditional croissants and sourdough bread. While the minimalist space often features long queues and limited seating, the exceptional quality and unique atmosphere make it a premier destination for Melbourne bakery enthusiasts.
Summary generated from 1,042 public reviews across Google, Broadsheet, Concrete Playground, Yelp, TripAdvisor, Facebook. Last updated recently · refreshed monthly.
The TopCafes review
A Sanctuary of Sourdough and Spirit
In the bustling landscape of Melbourne’s northern suburbs, few places managed to capture the collective heart of a neighbourhood quite like All Are Welcome. Located at 190 High Street, Northcote, the bakery occupied a site with a storied past, having served as a Christian Science Reading Room since the 1950s. The name itself was a serendipitous inheritance, taken directly from the gold-lettered signage that once adorned the front door of the cream-brick building. It was a moniker that felt both welcoming and slightly cultish, a duality that owner and baker Boris Portnoy embraced with open arms as he sought to create a space that felt less like a precious cafe and more like a functional, community-focused utility.
From Michelin Stars to Melbourne Mornings
Before he became a fixture of the Northcote high street, Boris Portnoy was navigating the high-pressure world of fine dining as the head pastry chef at The Restaurant at Meadowood, a three-Michelin-starred institution in California’s Napa Valley. Seeking a departure from the rigid perfectionism of fine dining, Portnoy moved to Melbourne in 2013, trading the white-tablecloth environment for the honest, tactile rhythm of a neighbourhood bakery. His philosophy was simple yet profound: to treat baking as a craft that celebrates the slight variations in every loaf, rather than the sterile uniformity of a laboratory. By collaborating with Mark Free and Aaron Maxwell of Everyday Coffee, he ensured that the caffeine programme was as rigorous as the oven work, creating a synergy where neither element felt like an afterthought.
The Architecture of Community
Stepping into the space, one was immediately struck by the light-filled, minimalist aesthetic that respected the building’s ecclesiastical origins. Architect Murray Barker’s fit-out cleverly repurposed reclaimed materials, including pews and wood panelling, to create an atmosphere that felt both historic and refreshingly modern. The exposed kitchen was the beating heart of the room, allowing regulars to watch the small team prepare for the following day’s bake, effectively stripping away the mystery of production. It was a place where the demographic was as broad as the menu, with locals and visitors alike finding common ground over a shared appreciation for artisanal technique.
"We don’t dumb things down; we try to tell the story as is. We assume that people are smart and our customers will ask questions. We have pastries with their original name."
A Menu Without Borders
What truly set All Are Welcome apart was its refusal to cater to the predictable. While the sourdough and rye loaves were foundational, the menu was a global tapestry of flavour. The khachapuri—a Georgian cheese-filled bread—became a cult favourite, as did the medovnik, a complex, 10-layer Russian honey cake that demanded patience and precision. The viennoiserie was equally exceptional, with flaky, buttery layers that spoke to Portnoy’s pedigree, while the coffee programme, featuring single-origin espresso and batch-brew filter, provided the perfect, clean-cut accompaniment to the richness of the pastries. It was a larder of delights, stocked with house-made preserves, pickles, and chutneys that encouraged customers to take a piece of the bakery home with them.
The Verdict
All Are Welcome was more than just a bakery; it was a testament to the power of community-focused hospitality. By bridging the gap between world-class technical skill and the humble, everyday ritual of buying bread, it became a cornerstone of Northcote’s cultural identity. While the queues were often long and the seating limited, the experience of standing in that light-filled room, surrounded by the scent of heritage grains and freshly roasted coffee, was a reminder of why Melbourne remains a global leader in cafe culture. It was a rare example of a venue that lived up to its name, offering a genuine sense of belonging to anyone who walked through its doors.
Independent editorial review by TopCafes. All Are Welcome has not paid for placement or coverage.
1,042
6
Google · Broadsheet · Concrete Playground · Yelp · TripAdvisor · Facebook
Rating breakdown
Scores by criteria
Opening hours
Opening hours
- Monday7:00 – 15:00
- Tuesday7:00 – 15:00
- Wednesday7:00 – 15:00
- Thursday7:00 – 15:00
- Friday7:00 – 15:00
- Saturday8:00 – 15:00
- Sunday8:00 – 15:00